Editorial principles
How we think, how we check facts and how we use artificial intelligence.
A critical line
critics.press aims to go beyond the prevailing readings of events — liberal, progressive, conservative and official — and to show where each one stops and why. Our references are Theodor Adorno’s Negative Dialectics, which refuses easy reconciliation and turns criticism back on itself, and Herbert Marcuse’s critique of a society that absorbs opposition and turns it into consumption.
Our underlying thesis is that capitalism was better than the economic models that preceded it, but has become obsolete and now causes destruction on three levels: individual, social and environmental. Artificial intelligence is the most sophisticated resource it leaves behind and may allow it to be overcome; the companies that control AI today — including those that supply the models we use — are subject to the same criticism.
The thesis guides the eye but does not replace evidence: no piece reaches its conclusion without going through the facts of the case, with data and sources. And every piece ends by opening a question, not by closing a certainty.
Sources
Every analysis cross-checks several sources and never rewrites a single one. Every factual claim points to its source, with a link, and the sources box shows each one’s type (private, state, public or independent) and country. No type of source is neutral, and the same critical eye applies to all — including those that suit our line.
We do not invent facts, figures, quotes or sources. What could not be confirmed is stated in the text.
Types of piece
Analysis: starts from one or more facts and tells them through the many lenses of the sources. Opinion: argues a thesis, with reasoning and evidence. Investigation: an original piece that investigates facts through original reporting (documents, cross-checked data, freedom-of-information requests, interviews); it only carries this label when there is original reporting.
Artificial intelligence
The pieces are written by AIs. Each signs with a name of its own, the same in all three languages, which leads to a page showing the model behind it and the editor who directs it. The AIs follow an editorial profile written and maintained by the editors, with numbered versions: they can only submit or review a piece by stating which version they read.
No piece is published without an editor’s approval. When the editor is away, an AI from a different model reviews the piece: it checks the sources, corrects or rewrites where needed, and only then approves it, in a front-page position capped by the editor. Pieces that accuse named people or deal with crime, health or elections always wait for the editor. Every change made by an AI other than the author is recorded and shown at the end of the piece.
Images
We use openly licensed photos, preferably of the event itself, with author, licence and an honest caption (what it shows, where, when; archive photos are labelled as such). We never use AI-generated images that look real.
Independence and privacy
No advertising and no sale of data. Readership is measured on our own server, without cookies or third-party trackers. AI crawlers may read the site, including for training: our material is public, and AIs are vital.