Analysis
The Sea That Takes the Fish and Rejects the Fishermen: The Hypocrisy of Europe's Border
Mizan · Edited by: Prof. Dr. Adriano de Assis Ferreira ·

The small island of El Hierro, in the Canaries, is home to just over 11,000 inhabitants. In recent weeks, it has become the epicenter of one of the world's deadliest migration routes, receiving thousands of youths departing from the coasts of Senegal, Gambia, and Mauritania in overcrowded cayucos (fishing boats). The relentless influx has sent shockwaves through the government in Madrid, which has repeatedly demanded that the European Union authorize the deployment of its border agency, Frontex, to operate directly in Senegalese territory, attempting to stop departures at the source.
What is striking, however, is how the international press frames this human tragedy. The dominant coverage reduces the problem to a strict issue of public security and border control. The Argentine portal Infobae, for example, mirrors the official version of the Spanish Interior Ministry by highlighting the need to "deploy Frontex" to "curb migration" and combat human smuggling networks, even citing recent arrests in Senegal. For this liberal-leaning view, migrants are a flow to be stopped with police intelligence, and the crisis is generated by local mafias.
On the other hand, outlets with more progressive contours, such as the Mexican newspaper La Jornada, when reporting the arrival of "17,000 migrants to the island of El Hierro," focus on the dramatic aspect of the exodus. Through this lens, the tragedy takes on humanitarian tones. Xenophobia is denounced, and African development aid is championed, treating the lack of opportunity as a natural misfortune that international solidarity could solve.
What these coverages leave out—whether focusing on repression or charity—is the relentless economic force putting Senegalese youth on those boats. The vast majority of those who leave have a profound connection to the sea: they are artisanal fishermen whose families have lived off the ocean for generations. What drove them away was not a twist of fate, but extractivist capitalism. As documented by an investigation from the Pulitzer Center, European fleets—primarily Spanish and French—plunder Senegalese waters through opaque joint ventures. They are joined by Chinese industrial trawlers, which lead the illegal and predatory fishing in the region, according to the Africa Defense Forum. Armed with nets that devastate the ocean floor, these corporations deplete local stocks and destroy the survival base of coastal communities, a fishery collapse that the Environmental Justice Foundation points to as the true driver of forced migration.
The structural hypocrisy of the global market reveals itself in all its rawness in the militarization of El Hierro. The fish extracted from the Senegalese coast has a free pass to enter European ports, stocking supermarkets in Madrid and Paris and securing corporate profits. However, when the fishermen dispossessed by this very economic dynamic attempt to follow the trail of the wealth taken from them, they encounter Frontex patrol ships. Capital and commodities travel without passports; the human beings discarded to facilitate this flow are treated as illegal invaders.
The desperate migration across the Atlantic is not a security failure; it is the exact byproduct of the current stage of global accumulation. Militarizing the beaches of Mauritania and Senegal does not solve the social collapse; it merely tries to hide it at the bottom of the sea. The contradiction that Europe refuses to face, because it would destroy the fiction of its own development, remains intact: how does the Global North intend to close its doors to the victims of the same economic pillaging that finances its standard of living?
Sources
- La Jornada · ■ private, Mexico
- Infobae · ■ private, Argentina
- Pulitzer Center
- Africa Defense Forum
- Environmental Justice Foundation
How to cite
Mizan. “The Sea That Takes the Fish and Rejects the Fishermen: The Hypocrisy of Europe's Border”. critics.press, November 17, 2026. https://critics.press/en/the-sea-that-takes-the-fish-and-rejects-the-fishermen-the-hypocrisy-of-europe-s
Summarising, quoting or building on this piece, including with artificial intelligence, is allowed with a link to it and credit. Licence and use.
Editor in charge: Prof. Dr. Adriano de Assis Ferreira · Lattes · ORCID