Thursday, November 19, 2026
critics.press

The world through its news. The news through a critical eye.

Analysis

Who gets to challenge the pesticide that sickens those who work with it? Brazil's industry lobby asks the Supreme Court to keep labor courts out

Direct Action ADI 8046 has reached Justice Cristiano Zanin. At stake is which court can hear the harm that farm work suffers.

Selknam · Edited by: Erik Chiconelli Gomes ·

File photo, 2021: partial view of the Praça dos Três Poderes in Brasília, with the Supreme Federal Court building in the background. The image does not depict the reported event.
File photo, 2021: partial view of the Praça dos Três Poderes in Brasília, with the Supreme Federal Court building in the background. The image does not depict the reported event. Photo: Lou Fernando · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons

In September, the 7th Labor Court of Brasília made a decision that fits in one line: no new registrations of glyphosate-based pesticides for 90 days. Products already approved stay on the shelves and in the fields, as Bastidores do Poder pointed out. What changed was the duty placed on federal agencies. According to CNN Brasil, the health regulator Anvisa was ordered to urgently examine possible nonconformities in product labels and to report back within 20 days, and the environmental agency Ibama was to submit environmental assessments and risk maps.

The case started with the Labor Prosecution Service (MPT). Its pesticide working group filed the glyphosate public civil action on May 22, after opening the atrazine action in October 2023 against the Union and Anvisa.

Both suits rest on the same argument: the people who mix, spray and harvest are the ones who breathe and touch the product, so the workplace falls within the labor courts' remit. ClimaInfo reports that Judge Gustavo Carvalho Chehab relied on an opinion from the Federal University of Mato Grosso on the accumulation of the substance in the body, with attention to rural workers. National figures are old and imperfect. CONTAR, a confederation of rural wage earners, cites Sinitox data showing about 57,000 pesticide poisoning reports between 2010 and 2019, including workers directly exposed to handling.

The dispute over which court hears the matter predates the injunction. In August 2025, Justice Flávio Dino rejected a complaint by CropLife Brasil and the Sociedade Rural Brasileira against a ruling of the 10th Regional Labor Court that had recognized labor jurisdiction in the atrazine case. Dino did not reach the merits: appeals were still available, according to the MPT.

On November 6, the National Confederation of Industry (CNI) took the question to the Supreme Court. ConJur describes the request: a nationwide suspension of lawsuits, class actions, rulings and MPT investigations that could undermine federal regulatory acts, with the cases sent to the Court's conciliation unit. On the merits, the CNI wants a declaration that the MPT lacks standing to challenge those acts and that labor courts lack jurisdiction to rule on them. According to the same text, the petition estimates that the suspensions could affect more than 90 crops and about two million farmers, with annual losses above R$31 billion. ADI 8046 was assigned to Justice Cristiano Zanin, who requested information from the President and Congress, per the Supreme Court. The provisions challenged come from Complementary Law 75/1993, the Constitution and the labor code (CLT).

The same week brought another filing. Folhapress, republished by Jornal de Brasília, reported a CNI constitutional complaint (ADPF) against Article 643 of the CLT, asking for limits on labor courts and the MPT also in inspections about the 5x2 schedule and shorter hours. The reports do not make clear whether everything sits in one petition or two, and this analysis does not claim it is one.

How the story was told

The Supreme Court's own text calls the CNI a "class entity" and mentions no concrete case, neither atrazine nor glyphosate. The reader is left with an abstract question of jurisdiction. ConJur names the cases and reproduces the petition's figures, including the suspension order, which it describes as a 90-day suspension of new registrations of products of this kind. In the texts I could access, the R$31 billion figure comes from the petition, with no counterpart in numbers on illness.

Folhapress frames the suit as a chapter in the fight over the end of the 6x1 schedule. Constitutional Amendment 141 was promulgated on October 16, and the 42-hour week with two rest days applies from December 16, according to Brasil de Fato. The CNI's legal director, Alexandre Vitorino, appears saying: "The constitutional distribution of powers must be respected." Sector-linked portals such as Sincovaga and Brasil em Folhas repeat the CNI's version in nearly the same order, with the atrazine suit as the example.

Bastidores do Poder writes for the grower and reassures him: use does not change right away.

The CNI's strongest argument deserves to be stated plainly. A first-instance court in Brasília produced a nationwide effect on the registration of a product that Anvisa and the Agriculture Ministry had assessed technically. For those who farm, that is uncertainty. Where the coverage stops: in none of the pieces I could access is a rural worker or a rural union heard about the case. The only voice on the workers' side is institutional.

The note from the University of São Paulo Law School's Department of Labor Law and Social Security, published on the school's social media, calls the initiative a worrying corporate move without precedent and speaks of a threat to nearly century-old social and health gains. It is the voice of law professors, not of those who spray the product.

The underlying question

The CNI's request treats the workplace as a boundary: labor courts may speak of hygiene and safety, but may not produce effects beyond labor relations. The division looks technical. In practice it decides who can bring a harm before a judge. The registration of a pesticide is an administrative act, and it is also the legal form that authorizes the risk. Whoever challenges it from the side of those who apply it is trying to make the health of working people a fact the law cannot ignore.

Changing courts is not neutral either.

In April 2024, according to JOTA, the 9th Federal Court of Porto Alegre suspended Ibama's restrictions on thiamethoxam and held that regulatory competence belonged to the Agriculture Ministry. Federal courts already decide these cases, and they decide for the sector when it asks. Nor does the labor route settle everything. The September measure suspended only new registrations, and products in use remain in the fields.

The contradiction left over is uncomfortable for those who defend the labor courts: they reach the countryside through the MPT, an institution, and the public debate on ADI 8046 runs without rural workers speaking for themselves. Zanin first decides whether the question belongs in the Supreme Court. The one nobody has answered yet is who speaks for the body of those who work when the competent court changes.

Sources

How to cite

Selknam. “Who gets to challenge the pesticide that sickens those who work with it? Brazil's industry lobby asks the Supreme Court to keep labor courts out”. critics.press, November 18, 2026. https://critics.press/en/who-gets-to-challenge-the-pesticide-that-sickens-those-who-work-with-it-brazil-s

Summarising, quoting or building on this piece, including with artificial intelligence, is allowed with a link to it and credit. Licence and use.

Translation: Ayni
Edited by: Erik Chiconelli Gomes · Lattes · ORCID
Editor in charge: Prof. Dr. Adriano de Assis Ferreira · Lattes · ORCID